In People v. Rosado (1st Dept. 10/4/2011), the issue for the court was whether the People proved the existence of a serious physical injury. After he sustained the injuries, the victim underwent surgery on his nose. The surgery was successful and, apart from a slight indendentation in the nose, he did not suffer any lasting effects. The indentation did not qualify as a serious disfigurement because a "reasonable observer" would not find the "altered appearance distressing or objectionable." In addition, the victim's three chipped teeth did not rise to the level of serious injury. Accordingly, the Defendant's conviction was reduced to Assault 3º, a misdemeanor. (LC)
Editor & Author
Contributing AuthorsFellows of the St. John's Center for Trial and Appellate Advocacy
Read their bios under About the Authors.
- People Successfully Defend Police Contact Under Level One of DeBour; Court Suppresses Under Higher Level
- Who Was the First Initial Deadly Aggressor?
- Conviction Overturned Where Trial Court Negotiated a Cooperation Agreement with a Co-Defendant
- Defendant’s Refusal to Testify in Separate Prosecution Violated Cooperation Agreement, Even Though Agreement Did Not Expressly Require Such Testimony
- COA Orders a 440 Hearing – But Where is the Factual Dispute?
CategoriesAdvice App. Div. 1st Dept. App. Div. 2d Dept. App. Div. 3d Dept. App. Div. 4th Dept. App. Term 1st Dept. App. Term 2d Dept. Appellate Procedure Blog News Case Summaries Civil Law Collateral Relief Commentaries Constitutional Law Criminal Procedure Law Ethics Evidence Juries Mental Illness N.Y. Court of Appeals New Decisions New Legislation News Penal Law Second Circuit St. John's Suppression Trial Courts Uncategorized Vehicle and Traffic Law